The police algorithm said that Lina is at the risk of ‘average’: then killed

In January, Lina went to the police.

The former partner threatened him in the House of Benalmádenan in Seaside of Spain. That day, he raised his hand as he hit him.

“There were severe episodes – feared,” said Lina’s cousin reminds Daniel.

When he arrived at the police station, he met Viogén, who was a digital vehicle that assessed the probability of attack again by the same person and his work.

Viogén – an algorithm-based system – abuse and intensity, aggressive weapons, mental health and woman to leave or leave or leave or leave.

He then marks the threats such as “insignificant”, “low”, “medium”, “high” or “extreme”.

The category is used to make decisions related to the separation of police resources to protect women.

Lina was considered to be at the risk of “average”.

Malaga asked for a restrictive order in the trial of violence in order to avoid contact or contact him or contact him or contact him. The request was rejected.

“Lina wanted to change the locks in his house, so he could live peacefully with his children,” he said.

Three weeks later, he died. It was alleged that the house was used to enter his partner’s straight and burned the house soon.

The children, his mother and former partners were not all who flee, Lina was not. His 11-year-old son said he was the father who killed his mother, he said.

The lifeless body of Lina was taken from the interior of the house. The former partner, the father of the three youngest children was arrested.

Now his death asks questions about the ability to keep women safe in Viogén and Spain.

Viogén did not predict the danger to Lina.

As a woman determined at the risk of “Medium”, the protocol, as a candidate for 30 days, as a police officer will be followed again.

Lina died before. If he was “high” risky, the police would take place in a week. Can you make a change for Lina?

Means are used in North America and Europe to estimate the threat of repeated domestic violence. Some police forces in the UK (evaluation of domestic violence risks) – the essentially testing list uses. And as police or others such as dashes (domestic violence, rape and honorary evaluation), such as policies or others, can be used to evaluate another attack.

However, it is just a strong woven algorithm to the police experience in Spain. Made by Viogén, Spanish police and scholars. It is used everywhere in the Basque country and catalyst (police cooperation in these regions, albeit on a national scale, there are separate systems).

Malaga describes the head of the National Police Family and Women’s Unit, Chesh Ishs Isabel Espejo, Viogén describes “super important”.

“This helps to monitor every victim’s work very clearly.”

Officials are engaged in the average sheet of sexuality on average day. And each month viogén classifies nine or 10 women as at the risk of “extreme”, which is repeated.

In these cases, the results of the resource are great: the cases for a woman for a 24-hour woman and the risk decreases. Women are evaluated as a “high” risk can accompany an officer.

In 2014, a study accepted the assessment of the possibility of viogen’s repeated abuse of officials. Critics offer to refuse to decide for an algorithm on the security of the police.

CH Inspepojo, the calculation of the risk of algorithm is generally adequate. However, he recognizes – Although the work of Lina is not in its commandment – something was wrong with the assessment of Lina.

“I’m not going to say that Viogén did not fail – it was not a trigger that caused this woman to be killed. He is a person who killed the only sinner.

However, Lina at the risk of “average” was never a police priority. And Lazan’s Viogén’s assessment affected the decision to deny his command to the court’s former partner?

The judiciary did not allow the judge to meet the judge who rejected a command against Lina, who attacked a woman who attacked a woman who died of Lina after Lina’s death.

Instead, one of the judges of Malaga’s sexual violence, Maria del Carmen Gutiérrez explains that such an order needs two things in general conditions: the evidence of such an order and a serious threat to the victim.

“Viogén is an element I use to assess this danger, but it is more than oddly,” he says.

Sometimes the judge restricts the rules restricted in cases where Viogen is “insignificant” or “low” risk. In other cases, it does not pose any threat to the lack of danger for a woman considered to be a “mean” or repeated damage.

Dr. Juan Jose Medina, a criminologist at Seville University, a “zip code lottery” for women applying for the restriction of Spain – some jurisdictions are more likely to give more than others. However, we do not systematically systematically systematically systematically affect the trials or how the viogen has affected the courts or the police.

“How are police officers and other stakeholders who use this tool, and how do we do it? We do not have good answers,” he said.

The Spanish Ministry of Internal Affairs often does not allow scientists to access viogen. And algorithm did not have an independent audit.

Gemma Galdon, OTIC’s founder – an organization that works on the social and ethical effect of technology – you do not know if you do not check these systems, the protection of the police to protect the police.

Algorithmic biased samples in other places are well documented. In the United States, the analysis of the 2016 analysis of a recidivism was more likely to be considered a mistake for the higher the risk of his white peers. At the same time, white defendants will be false as a higher risk of black defendants.

In 2018, the Spanish Ministry of Internal Affairs did not give a green light to a hotikas offer to hold confidential, bono and internal audit. Thus, instead of Gemma Galdon and colleagues, Viogén decided to make a hesitant engineer and foreign audit.

They used interviews with internal exploitation and open information – were killed, including information about women like Lina.

Between 2003 and 2021, 71 women killed by their partners or former partners, they previously found their local abuse. The “insignificant” or “insignificant” or “environment” risk levels were given in the Viogén system.

“What we wanted to know was this wrong ratios, which could not be eased in any way? Or can these systems give you the risk of how these systems give and those women better maintain?” Gemma asks Galdon.

Juan José Lopez-Ossorio, head of gender violence research in the Spanish Interior Ministry, was rejected by Obetas investigation: Viogén did not perform. “If you don’t have access to data, how can you comment on it?” Says.

And he fears a foreign audit that fears that both women can concessure to the security of women with viogén procedures.

“What we know, a woman tells a woman to a man, and it is under the protection of the police, the more violence is significantly lowered – we do not doubt it,” said López-Ossorio.

Viogén has been developed since it was applied in Spain. The survey is cleared and the “insignificant” risk category will be canceled soon. Even critics agree to have a standard system that meets the sexual violence.

Benalmádenada, the house of Lina has become the tomb.

The pictures of the flowers, candles and the saints were stepped. A small placard attached to the wall was announced: Benalmádena says no sex. Society financed for the children of Lina.

His cousin said Daniel, everyone is aware of the news of death.

“The family of this destroyed – especially the mother of the linen,” he says.

“It is 82. I don’t think your daughter is not more sad than the aggressor is killed in a way that is prevented. They are still shocked – they will need a lot of psychological assistance.”